Crossing the Line
In life, there often seems to be a line where many things move from being a positive to a negative. From a healthy part of our existence to an unhealthy one. From a functional and normal process to a dysfunctional and abnormal one. From something that should be life-enhancing, to something that becomes potentially life-destroying.
Food
Take food, for example. Over the years, I’ve worked with many people who have turned their healthy eating habits into completely unhealthy eating disorders. Somewhere along the way, they went from being focused on eating well, to being totally obsessed with, and preoccupied by, food. Something which is fundamental to human existence and survival (eating) somehow becomes their biggest challenge in life. The very thing that will sustain most of us, might well destroy them.
Exercise
The same thing happens with exercise. The unfit person becomes fit. Before long, they feel better, look better, function better and get lots of approval and recognition – all highly desirable (and potentially addictive) outcomes. So, they decide to get a little fitter and leaner and train a little more. And more again. They reason: “Well, if one hour of exercise is good, then two hours will be twice as good and three must be amazing!” Before long, they train whenever and wherever possible. They begin to lie about their exercise habits. They experience anxiety and even anger when they can’t do their workout. They start planning their life around their exercise regime. It affects them mentally, emotionally and socially. They lose perspective and the healthy pursuit of exercise has now become an unhealthy obsession.
Money
We see this type of unhealthy behaviour in a range of settings and wrapped around a plethora of everyday issues and responsibilities. For some people, making money will transition from being a normal, everyday responsibility and necessity to a complete obsession. They will eat, sleep and breathe it. Money will become their identity. Their self esteem. Their sole focus. Or should I say, soul focus? And, in the middle of their fanatical pursuit of the almighty dollar, they will become physically, emotionally and spiritually bankrupt. They will lose themselves. Their success will not be success at all. Their practical and sensible goal (to earn and save money) will have become an unhealthy and destructive obsession.
Religion
And speaking of destructive and dysfunctional habits, behaviours and beliefs, I guess I could play the religion card… but do I really need to? Thought not.
Personal Development
So, let’s talk about the potential dangers of personal development instead; the reason I started this long-winded monologue. “But Craig, surely immersing myself in personal development can’t lead to any kind of undesirable or negative outcomes, can it?”
Er, only about a thousand.
Like anything else that we might focus on, the pursuit of personal growth can produce a myriad of negative outcomes when we go about it the wrong way. Some people will become quite fanatical and emotional about their new-found insight and reality. Which might compel them to evangelise their un-impressed family, friends and colleagues with an ever-expanding range of theories, ideas, stories and shonky research. And, naturally, that’s always well received.
For the most part, being excited, educated and passionate about something is good, especially when it leads to some kind of positive behavioural change and desirable outcome. When the information (like the mountains of stuff on this site) is the genesis for practical application and lasting transformation, then personal development is serving its intended purpose. It’s positive. It’s practical. It’s transformational. It’s a valuable resource.
The Reality
But when we step back from all the motivational language, the theories, the mantras, the affirmations and the emotion, can we honestly say that personal development products, programs, services and resources typically (that is, most times) result in significant and lasting transformation for the individuals who partake? Of course, there is no independent data or research to answer that question accurately or quantitatively (to my knowledge) but if I had to take an educated stab my answer would be… no, most people don’t create significant or lasting change. That’s not to say that they can’t but, rather, that they won’t.
Life Ain’t No Theory
For some people, the answer will be yes but it’s my experience, observation and opinion that far too many people delude, delay and deny themselves in the theory of transformation (yes, even people who frequent this cyber-classroom) when they should actually be rolling up their sleeves and immersing themselves in the practical, messy, uncomfortable reality of the change process. The doing part.
Which (Finally) Leads Me to My 90/10 Rule…
After decades of teaching, coaching, learning, studying and watching this stuff in action, I’m of the opinion that, for personal development to be a genuinely effective transformational tool – in a practical, measurable and experiential way – the change process should be somewhere in the vicinity of ninety percent doing stuff (the practical) and ten percent learning stuff (listening, watching, reading, researching, studying). Of course, the percentages might need to vary a little depending on the individual goal and what stage of the journey we’re at with that goal but, for the most part, I think 90/10 works.
Sadly, for many people, the percentages are more like 1/99. That is, one percent doing and ninety-nine percent… not doing.
What are your percentages?
* Don’t forget my new kid’s book (The Angry Ant) is out now! Love this article? Sign up for my FREE Email Newsletter today to receive more articles like this, and get my FREE Ebook!









{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }
with 3 kids??? The only time I am NOT doing stuff is when I am sleeping……..or on facebook of course
Hi Craig,
I definitely agree with your rule. I often say that unfortunately, we have more personal development readers than doers, which is why many people don’t really change. Fundamentally, developing new skills and attitudes is about repetitive practice, not inspirational lecture.
Right on, Craig! If I had spent just 50% of the time I spent theorizing on doing, instead of my current 10% doing/90% theory ratio I would be at 55% doing/45% theory and I might have accomplished more than just sitting around doing some thinking.
But sitting around thinking is compelling because you BELIEVE you’re being productive and it’s EASIER to project doing than to do doing. More delusion.
The other thing is that thinking about doing something is light years faster than actually doing it. So if you believe that thinking = doing, then you also probably think you’re getting more done faster, when you’re actually doing nothing. Witness my shelf of self-help volumes and my lists of plans.
Many opportunities have passed me by while I was believing I was doing real work and it turned out I was only thinking about doing it. Not only because it’s EASIER, but because it’s LESS SCARY. Theoretical doing incurs far less risk. So today I’m going to really take that risk. Hopefully I’ll be able to continue taking that risk everyday. And that 10% theory? I think I’ll try to limit it to some daily motivational reading. Thanks.
Great stuff Craig. My percentages depend on whether I am trying to learn something new or not. Usually I try to stick to 75/25, but if I have to take the time to learn something that’s going to help me out later, I might go all the way to 100% learning for a short period to get it out of the way. It is a major motivation sapper though.
I am guilty of the 1/99 ratio…
And to be honest the total effort is a total of an hour a week right now.
Does the fact that I have no delusions about how little progress I make (and that it is totally up to me to make changes) make that ratio worse or better??
I think I’m about 90/10 – not because I’m a spectacular “do-er” but because I just don’t spend time on the theory. I read this blog update twice a week and that’s about it really. I do also think and reflect, I just don’t obsess.
A recent “daily thought” on my calendar says that many people who are busy looking for four leaf clovers in the back yard will not hear opportunity knock at the front door.
Every day is an opportunity to do something. If it’s about getting fit and losing weight (which is my task) then every day is an opportunity to live well. If I spend an hour walking I feel great. If I spend an hour on the sofa with a “self-help” manual I just end up with a cramped back.
The choices are easy. Just make them. If you have read ten books about how to “live your best life” what do you honestly think book number eleven can offer.
Living like your days are unlimited is a terrible kind of extravagance that you simply can not afford.
Hi Craig,
My experience of personal development has been a little different to what you described.
I moved house a few years ago, and cleaned out my bookshelves only taking the really helpful ‘self-help’ books with me. I have found them invaluable for keeping me focused and helping me sort out problems as they crop up.
Naturally they all say pretty much the same thing: stop trying to control others and take responsibility for your own life, but it’s helpful to dip into them from time to time for reinforcement (especially when I find myself blaming someone else for something that is wrong in my life!).
I was a say a 30/70 until I read Craigs ‘Woulda, Coulda, Shoulda’ post a few weeks ago. Now I am about a 60/40 and working on improving on that. When I get to 90/10 in the not too distant future I will have changed my life, then its a matter of making 90/10 a habit!
That hamburger looks fantastic!
A very good pun and a fine oxymoron.
I was always dreadful at mathematics and have not really sought to change that. I only need to divide and multiply for exchange rate conversion – or that’s my goal! So percentages are not my thing. But I reckon I’m 100/100. Or 0/0. Because I only ever learn from doing and experiencing. Nothing makes much sense to me until I have made it 3D real for myself. I can read the best books, hear the best teachers, but the only time I ever learn is when I DO…
Does that make me 100/100….
By my calculations, anyway…
I have to consciously force myself into the doing part, not just for personal development, multiple times throughout the day. It’s really easy for me to waste time otherwise.
{ 7 trackbacks }