Talent Versus Skill

Hi Guys. Not a very sexy topic today, but a relevant and valuable discussion for most of us nonetheless. I hope your weekend was fun and I also hope you found some time to send a few dollars to our friends in Haiti. If you’ve been feeling a little bit sorry for yourself lately just take a peek at some of the footage coming out of that devastated country and you might find some perspective. I have. Problems are all relative aren’t they? What we (often) call hardship, some people would call heaven.

On with the show…

Success or Failure

Have you ever wondered what it is that determines success or failure? Success in sport? In business? At school? In negotiating a deal? In losing weight? Or better still, keeping weight off? In leading a team? Resolving conflict? Solving a  problem? Becoming a successful singer? Artist? Pilot? Inventor? Business owner? Parent? Writer? Entrepreneur? Speaker? 

While there’s no simple (or single) answer to that question - being as there are many variables - without doubt, two of the most important ingredients in the success recipe are talent and skill. One is totally out of our control, in that it’s in-built, fixed and we’ll never have any more or less of it. It is what it is. The other is completely subject to our choices, mindset and subsequent behaviours. That is, we have the ability and the opportunity to develop it – often beyond a level we would have believed possible – if we’re prepared to do what it takes to get there. Wherever there is. 

Here’s what we know:

Average Ability + Method + Work + Courage = skill development, improved performance and greater likelihood of success.

Above Average Ability (Gifted) + Laziness + Poor Attitude + Fear = frustration, poor performance, wasted potential and little chance of success.

Talent is Only the Starting Point

If you need a brilliant and inspirational example of how skill can be developed with unbelievable work ethic, passionate commitment, fierce determination and just a little courage ;) , take a trip to see Cirque du Soleil some time. Now that is some serious skill – which is the result of some serious work. Over a long period of time. Sure they’re talented individuals, but not one of those performers would be on stage if they had not spent years (and years) acquiring, developing, refining and further refining their skills. Talent is only the starting point. With all endeavors.

By itself, talent will get us nowhere.

Vroom, Vroom….

Imagine that your talent is a Ferrari. It is powerful. Attractive. Exciting. It has enormous untapped potential. And best of all, it’s right there at your fingertips. You just need to turn the key and drive it. It can take you where other cars can’t. It can take you on the trip of a lifetime. It can give you overwhelming joy, pleasure and excitement. It can also scare the shit out of you. Metaphorically. I hope. If only you’d take it out of the garage to see what it can do.

It’s true, many of us are so petrified of crashing the car, hurting ourselves and/or looking stupid that we never even engage first gear; let-alone take that bad boy out of the garage to explore its considerable potential. And while we’re parked in neutral and drooling on the dashboard, our Hyundai-driving friends with far less power and potential at their disposal are exploring the outer-reaches of their… er… car. That is, developing some amazing (and life-changing) skills by using more of what they’ve got. While we’re looking at the four walls of our stupid garage and smelling the Italian leather, they’re out covering massive ground, doing what most won’t do and turning their dreams into reality. Their car doesn’t have nearly the potential of our car, but they’re using every ounce of what it has. And then some. Who knew a Hyundai could do that? Yowzer.

Consciously Developing Skills

Depending on our life-goals, we will need a little (or perhaps a lot, depending on the goal) of each - talent and skill – in order to be able to create the kind of results we want to see in our world. While most of us come to sites like this because we want to produce better results and live our best lives, the reality is that many of us don’t methodically and consciously work towards developing and improving the relevant and necessary transformational skills. We simply get out of bed and do what we did yesterday, last week, last month and last year. We do the same. Talk the same. Choose the same. Think the same. React the same. And then we wonder why we live in Groundhog Day. If our goal is constant improvement and consistently better results, then skill development should be a conscious, methodical, intentional and consistent part of our overall transformation strategy.

The Skill of Communication

Take communication for example: without doubt, it is the most important interpersonal skill. It can make or break careers, businesses, negotiations, marriages, friendships, families, all kinds of relationships and even governments, yet how many of us consciously work to become more effective, skilled and empowered communicators? Almost none – that’s how many. While some people are naturally gifted communicators, it’s a skill we all need and a skill we can (and should) all develop methodically. I’m amazed at how many people in positions of influence, responsibility and even leadership (which is most of us, by the way) are constantly shooting themselves (and others) in the foot courtesy of their inability to create meaningful and productive communication and connection with others.

Talent

Some people are truly gifted and their considerable talent is apparent from an early age. Evidence of such precocious and prodigious talent can be witnessed before some children can even hold a meaningful conversation. Sadly, my only early talent was for locating and consuming food. I was indeed resourceful  – at the finding - and prolific – at the consuming. It’s fair to say I was something of a caloric prodigy. Some might say a human Golden Retriever. Woof, woof. Whether their inbuilt and obvious talent (back to the child prodigies now) will eventually translate to success will be determined by (1) their ability to maximise that potential and (2) their ability to develop the relevant skills to complement their inherent gift.  

Wasting or Maximising?

One of the key questions for this discussion is not “how much ability do I have” but rather, “how much of that ability will I use?”. We all know very talented people who have spent years finding new and creative ways to waste their talent. We also know people who have not been blessed with vast amounts of natural ability yet have constantly found a way to squeeze every ounce out of what they’ve been born with – while simultaneously developing their skills to a level that sees them consistently producing incredible results.

The Not-Very-Talented Me

Here’s a short list of the some of what keeps me busy at the moment (in my professional life): blogging (this site), media (TV, radio), writing (books, magazines) professional speaking (corporate, health clubs, teams, conferences, public workshops), performance coaching (teams and individuals), physical conditioning (teams and individuals), business management and development (my own gym, other opportunities). 

While I work, and have worked, with many talented and gifted individuals over the last twenty-eight years (yep, I’m that old), it’s fair and honest to say I’m not a particularly talented person. I know some people might not believe that, but it’s true. However, I am driven, I do work hard, I do ask better questions (than many), I am resilient (by choice), I will acknowledge and develop my (numerous) flaws, I am prepared to keep learning and while most are finding an excuse, I will find a way.

Probably the only real talent that I demonstrated from a relatively young age (apart from my gift for eating, of course) was communication. While I’ve subsequently become reasonably skilled and proficient in several areas, my development has always been the result of my conscious and focused efforts to acquire the required skills in those areas. Take a peek at the following necessary-for-my-life skills that I have consciously developed over the last few decades (and will continue to develop into the future). Next to each skill I have put two figures which denote how much of my current level of proficiency in that area is – what I perceive to be - the result of either (1) natural talent or (2) conscious and strategic skill development. The figures will add up to one hundred (percent) and I will use ‘S’ and ‘T’ to denote skill and talent.

  • Communication: T 60, S 40 – “Communication” is a pretty general term and a multi-faceted beast. It’s something I still work at every day.
  • Business Management and Development: T 20, S 80 – It’s fair to say I was a very ordinary (read, terrible) business man for the first decade.
  • Leadership: T 40, S 60 – While I have some (modest) talent in this area, I didn’t become a decent leader until I committed to do the necessary work.
  • Managing Staff: T 30, S 70 – Years of making mistakes was good training in this area. Apologies to my employees.
  • Conflict Resolution: T 15, S 85 – Believe it or not, I was once a chronic people pleaser. Apparently I can’t keep everyone in the world happy. Who knew?
  • Finances: T 20, S 80 – The only financial ‘skill’ I had when I started my company was to waste obscene amounts of money… on nothing in particular.
  • Writing: T 30, S 70 – You think my writing is crap now… you should have seen it a decade ago!
  • Negotiation: T 20, S 80 – People pleasers are not good negotiators. Still a work in progress for me.
  • Decision Making: T 20, S 80 – In my early days I was a world champion at not making significant (and necessary) decisions. Thankfully, I’ve changed.

The Last Bit

While my reality and experience is not necessarily representative of anyone else, my journey has provided me with the incredible opportunity to work with, and observe, thousands of amazing people all striving to improve their world in some way. Of course it’s impossible to quantify the answer to the ’Talent Versus Skill’ question but I think it’s fair to say that as a rule, talent might open the door, but only skill will take us to our desired destination.

As always, love your thoughts on this topic. :)

Love this article? Sign up for my FREE Email Newsletter today to receive more articles like this, and my FREE Ebook!

Post Footer automatically generated by Add Post Footer Plugin for wordpress.

{ 1 trackback }

Tweets that mention Talent Versus Skill -- Topsy.com
January 25, 2010 at 12:47 pm

{ 20 comments… read them below or add one }

Zal January 24, 2010 at 10:24 pm

Hi Craig,

I totally agree with talent and skill. Many people never reach their true potential due to limiting beliefs.
I have seen a clear example of this with my career, I am still in contact with several people who have the exact same degree with (so talent is the same we are all good at maths!) there is 3 people I know who (after 4 years) have not found a job that utilizes there degree, they have been rejected a few times and given up. At the beginning I was rejected many time (I lost count!), I never gave up, I started up with a job that would pay the same as a checkout chic at Safeway, within 4 years I tripled my salary that because I knew I could achieve it.

Thanks Craig!

Reply

Lisa January 25, 2010 at 2:37 am

Dear Craig,
Since you’ve scientifically formulated your perception of the ratio of talent versus skill in all areas relevant to your profession, who could argue with the figures?

I read your posts and learn from them. I’ve even changed my behavior because the (supposed) gift you have for communicating has been so enlightening and butt-kicking.

By laying out the work you’ve put into developing these and the other skills, it leaves us with no excuse for not doing our own work.
Thank you, humble master ;)

I heard once that the people who succeed are often not the ones with the most talent, but the ones with the most audacity. They’re the ones who aren’t afraid to get “out there” and show the world what they offer. So, you’re right, we do need courage too.

talent + skill + circus-type practice + courage = Success :)

Regarding Haiti, Yes, money and prayers. What a helpless feeling to see the footage and just be able to do that much.

xox

Reply

Eduard @ Ideas With A Kick January 25, 2010 at 2:56 am

Hey Craig,

You make some strong points here. Relying just on talent rarely gets you far. On the other hand, I can’t help noticing that there are a lot of people out there who have no idea what their talents are and thus have a very low chance of leveraging them. This makes it even harder for them to achieve success. I believe we all have gifts, talents, but some of them are not that obvious and the challenge is to discover them despite this.

Reply

Doug in NM January 25, 2010 at 3:41 am

Hi Craig,

Once again, you’ve hit the proverbial nail on the head! We all have things we are good at and other things at which we totally suck. It is important that we be honest when evaluating our strengths and our weaknesses. Human nature being what is, we might want to have another person assist us in this exercise.

After identifying a weak area, we can begin to learn some specific skills to strengthen said weakness. As you say, persistance and commitment are essential in creating change-that is why I intend to stay connected to you.com so I can continue to benefit from your words of wisdom…as well as those who exchange their thoughts and ideas.

Reply

Jules January 25, 2010 at 5:39 am

Thanks for that, Uncle Craig. That was full of insight and clearly reflects years of personal experience and the work you have done with many (many) individuals and companies.

I’m yet to identify my real ‘talents.’ Other than the talent I clearly display for over-thinking/’worrying about stupid shit and talking a lot (about what I’m going to do). I’m only 30 though. Maybe by the time I get to your age I will have discovered what my talent(s) is/are? ;) Actually, I think it’s fair and reasonable to say I have a talent for caring. Possibly caring too much sometimes? I can take things a bit too personally. Need to learn to step back a bit, hey.

What I do know is that 2010 is going to be the most A-M-A-Z-I-N-G year for me. It can be for you too, if that’s what you choose. It ain’t that hard. You just have to want whatever it is you want enough so that you are 110% committed and focused to ‘it.’ A few big things in 2010 for me are: finishing my first ironman triathlon in… gulp… 39 days; getting to my target body composition of 18-21% body fat… and getting myself back on track with a career path (unsure what that may be yet – may be the same or different to the one I started in 2009),

I’m far from being what you may refer to as a ‘natural endurance athlete’ but the beauty of endurance sport is that if you put in the work, you can succeed, and can do quite well. I’d imagine wanting to be a 100m sprinter could be a bit different though? Anyway, all I know is that I’m willing to do WHATEVER IT TAKES to reach the goals that I set for myself (in conjunction with others I consider experts in the field – like you, Craig, and my ironman coach, Jason “Shorto” Shortis). Don’t adopt someone elses goals just ‘because it sounds/looks/smells good.’ You have to do it for the RIGHT reasons. And only you can figure them out, in your own time. F*#!, look how long it has taken me to get to this point! Be guided by others, but don’t just be a follower like I have for so many years.

Reply

Cdn friend January 25, 2010 at 7:27 am

I love your car analogy, Craig!

I know that no matter what I do, there is always someone better at doing it, more talented, smarter, faster, stronger, etc. But it doesn’t stop me from participating – or at least it shouldn’t…

Reply

Kate January 25, 2010 at 10:30 am

Oh well then if it doesnt really matter if Im an Hyundai or a ferrari…Im going to be the red manual ferrari, as apparently they go faster and last longer! And i think that if I need to do the work anyway these are probably good things to have!

Reply

artemis January 25, 2010 at 10:47 am

Hi Craig,
very effective blog. You mention about creating what we want or transforming our lives into what we want, moving, taking action towards our goal(s). How about if you don’t have direction because you don’t know what you want. I feel as my life has changed with marriage,children and health issues this has made a huge impact on my previous goals and choices. I find there seems to be alot of material on teaching you direction for getting what you want but not on how to find out what you want.

We change and grow, we mature, and so do our choices or goals (anyway my did) so reading very inspirational info on how to achieve is wonderful but I feel it would help some ( like myself) and others to go one step backwards and receive guidance on how to find out what we want to achieve/become so that we can have this direction in life.

Craig when you speak about your life it always projects alot of happiness,growth,fulfillment and excitement. You are very lucky to be in a position which feeds you and makes you feel like you want to grow. I believe once a person has found what feeds them nothing stands in their way of continuous grow and fulfillment.

Reply

Em From Jem January 25, 2010 at 11:13 am

Hi Craig,

You’re right … not a very sexy topic, especially when I had a good think about it and realises I was wasting my talents!!
I went to school (many years ago) with a chick who was a very good (very, very good) athlete. Brilliant, natuarally talented sprinter. When she was about 15 she won an event called the Burnie Gift (I think it was Burnie … ) which is part of our Christmas carnival series here in Tassie (lots of mainlanders come down to race, we’ve have Cathy Freeman run, Craig Mottram … and Jana Rawlinson this year. Also lots of people use it as an early lead-up to Stawell). So, for us, it is a big deal and she won it at 15!!
Not long after that, she gave up on athletics. She didn’t like the training. I know it’s just conjecture …. but I reckon she could have been an Olympian … she was that good.
Fortunately I don’t have that much talent to waste!!!!
Nice post, Craigo. Thanks very much.
Em
( ) x

Reply

Phoenix Marshall January 25, 2010 at 11:27 am

I think in many ways talent versus skill can also be likened to the tortoise and the hare story. Because the hare was so much more gifted at racing than the tortoise it got lazy, and literally started taking a nap. This allowed the tortoise to overtake it.

You see this sort of thing happen a lot in the world of sport. A precocious young talent never reaching their full potential because they think they’ll be able to get by on natural talent alone. They neglect the training and hard work that is required to build on their talent.

Reply

Kate January 25, 2010 at 2:25 pm

Marshall, I have always loved the tortoise and the hare story because the tortoise ends up faster! Ironic

Reply

Jen January 25, 2010 at 2:56 pm

Great post, love this subject. Have rediscovered my love of learning, challenging and changing things in my life and now excited about what is next.

Reminded me of this quote I stumbled across one day and love it:

“Your talent determines what you can do. Your motivation determines how much you are willing to do. Your attitude determines how well you do it.” — Lou Holtz (a college football coach in USA)

cheers
Jen

Reply

PT to be January 25, 2010 at 3:07 pm

Great post craig!
I’m wanting to do cert 3 and 4 in fitness this year. I have the motivation and time to put in the hours, but I haven’t taken that step towards paying for the course yet. I’m worried about finding a job, once I am a qualified personal trainer, and then worrying about who is going to look after my 2 and 3 year olds, if I do find a job.
Stupid, I know, just typing this is making me realise that I am just holding myself back. If the motivation is there and you have some talent, I guess the next step is to make a commitment and take the plunge…

Thanks for your post….just the boost I needed, maybe I will register online for the course today :)

Reply

Michael January 25, 2010 at 6:12 pm

I would add confidence to the mix.

See the thing is there are billions of life forms on this planet and a handful care or hate you.

But in our own minds (mine at least) there is something that holds me back. It’s me. Oh yes of course there are many restrictions, age, qualifications etc, but basically it is some voice/s in their that stops us.

PT to be, that’s an example. Whilst it is realistic to expect some shuffling of priorities and looking after the children, they will come to learn you have a goal life. With me, it’s all about this i’m not good enough despite evidence to the contrary. I write a lot and there is a voice or rather a few from the past that are blocking me.

So courage in one way to me is just going, ok well, yeah it might fall over, but what if it doesn’t? I suppose it gets back to self-talk issues again.

artemis – don’t worry I feel directionless and don’t know what I want in many areas, but then again I fall back on one principle – take each day as it comes. Maybe in the daily is our direction? Maybe the gnawing that we don’t know what we want is from our perception and it’s really just in front of us. You’re doing fine as you are.

Meantime wish me luck with my paper it’s due Feb 1 and i’m hearing voices it isn’t good enough, but i’m going to let them go and write it.

“Don’t adopt someone else’s goals just ‘because it sounds/looks/smells good.’ You have to do it for the RIGHT reasons. And only you can figure them out, in your own time”

:)

Reply

Jules January 25, 2010 at 6:45 pm

What amazing timing. My 2010 ‘The Inspired Athlete’ page-a-day calendar for the weekend just gone says:
“Natural talent only determines the limits of your athletic potential. It’s dedication and a willingness to discipline your life that makes you great.”
- Billie Jean King
tennis legend and Tennis Hall of Fame member

*Do you have the same calendar too, Craig? Was that what sparked this post? I’d do a double back flip if you do! *I really love it. It’s really helping me build a solid foundation so I can be the best athlete I can be. And the best person I can be too, across other areas in life.

It’s what you teach day in day out, hey, Craig. It’s not about motivation. It’s about commitment, focus and discipline. Not all that sexy. But it works. And it’s what you make it. If you make it all harder than it needs to be, then that’s your issue. You can choose to make ‘it’ (ie. the commitment, focus and discipline to whatever it is your’re wanting to achieve) a non-negotiable part of your life just like having a shower and brushing your teeth is. OR you can make it a one of those chores that you really hate. It’s up to you. My eating and training regime is effortless now. I just do it. I don’t talk myself out of it. I work hard, sure – that bit requires physical effort, but I was referring to the mental effort.

PT to be – I’m considering doing the Cert III and IV in Fitness course too but I have my own self-doubts. The course is several grand hey. I’m thinking it’d take a fair few PT sessions to recoup the initial outlay of getting qualified. Then there’s the ongoing business costs if you’re going to be self-employed. Just think about it all before you commit. Don’t rush into it. How long does it take, realistically to build a client base so its a viable career path? I’m self-motivated now and believe I can motivate others. I’m passionate about life-long health and fitness and helping others to create a better life for themselves. What course are you looking at doing? I mean, which training provider?

Reply

Craig January 25, 2010 at 7:20 pm

Hi Zal, Lisa, Eduard, Doug, Jules, Cdn Friend, Kate, Artemis, Em Phoenix, Jen, PT to be and Michael – thanks for dropping by and sharing.

Artemis – good question. I’ll write an article on that issue soon – in the mean time… sometimes we can get more clarity about what we want by first identifying what we DON’T want – in and for our life.

Cheers…

Reply

Jerry O'Neil January 25, 2010 at 9:12 pm

Interesting article. I have had a similar experience in my life where I have had several skills that I have semi-consciously developed over time.

Also, after reading your article it is clear to me that perhaps I need to consider the level at which I have or don’t have a particular skill and make a clear plan to develop them. Otherwise, as you said, ground hog day rules.

(By the way I spent the first 10 years of my working life using formula two. Thankfully, with the help of a good manager, the second 10 years were spent using formula one.)

Reply

PT to be January 26, 2010 at 9:08 am

Jules,
Getting cert 3 and 4 in fitness is my short term goal. My long term goal in a few years time would be to have my own pt gym/studio. Right now its more about getting out of the house and motivating others and feeling like I have something to offer, other than being a mum and a wife. I don’t think you could get qualified and then just walk straight into having your own business (unless you already have alot of cash stashed away somewhere).
I’m hoping that there will be a few opportunities out there for me, either at my local gym, or putting in a few hours at sombody elses studio. I’m willing to work for free for a while, just to get some hours of experience and to see if its really what I want long term. I could always work for “harpers” hey craig? :) ….as its only a stones throw from my house…he he.

I have looked into a few courses online…but australian fitness network seems to be the way to go for me. (based in sydney)www.fitnessnetwork.com.au
If you pay upfront you can save yourself $900 off the total price. total costing $2,990
They also offer pay as you go for $85 a wk over 9 months total cost of $3,690
I’ve noticed alot of the other courses online are quite a bit more expensive for the same qualifications.

Reply

Jen January 26, 2010 at 3:31 pm

Hi Jules and PT to be, I recently enrolled to study Cert3&4 online through Fitnation. Have only just finished one module (submitted my assessment today so fingers crossed) but seems good so far and price was ok too.

Good luck, it took me a while to finally make the decision to do this (was trying to work out in my head if this was where I wanted to go 150%) but then decided, it was all learning about something I really enjoy so jump in.

cheers
Jen

Reply

SINGING MAGPIE February 28, 2010 at 8:06 pm

Hi Craig
thanks for your website.

I identify totally with Artemis. When I was a young woman my focus was on raising a family and my creative talents were used in looking after my family and in leisure. Now the youngest has flown from the nest and my husband is focussing on the need for me to contribute financially to our retirement planning.

I have never developed the creative talents that I have and a big thing is not knowing what I wanted to do most. I have sometimes thought that it would be easier if I was only talented at one thing.

My challenge is to identify what talent I can develop that I will enjoy doing and will earn an income. I look forward to the promised article.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: