Feeling Like a Fraud

So, I got smashed in the comments yesterday. Suck it up Harps. ;) Isn’t it great that we don’t all look at life through the same pair of glasses? How boring and bland that would be. Anyway, thanks to everyone (yep, everyone) for their input. I have taken it all on board and respect you for taking the time to participate. I’m all for some healthy debate and disagreement – until it gets ugly, personal or nasty. So let’s agree or disagree respectfully. :)

On with the show…

Over the last week (or so), four people in four different conversations have told me that they feel like a fraud. Often. What an interesting term. Rather than writing a new post on a topic that I’ve already spoken about, I thought I might dust off something I wrote not-too-long-ago and take it for another spin. It seems to be relevant and worth re-visiting.  

The Pretender

Put up your hand if you ever feel like a fraud. A fake? A phoney? A pretender? Me too. Even in the middle of some (relative) success,  I have often felt not ‘something’ enough. Not smart enough. Qualified enough. Experienced enough. Lean enough. Young enough. Old enough. Funny enough. Academic enough.

In short; not good enough.

A Literary Fraud

Despite being a successful blogger with lots of subscribers and a large readership, I have often felt like a literary fraud. A fake writer. A bloke who writes a lot but isn’t really a writer. After all, who starts a sentence with and or but? And, more importantly, who writes a book with the ‘F’ word on the cover? Surely a real writer wouldn’t do that?

So why does a guy who has written books, written for numerous magazines and newspapers and gets regular positive feedback about his writing doubt himself as a writer? Because (1) self-doubt doesn’t make sense (it’s not logical) and (2) it doesn’t discriminate.

The funny thing is, I often know one thing (intellectually) while feeling something else (emotionally). Been there? For example, even though I’ve presented to hundreds (maybe thousands) of audiences, there are still times when I feel like a fraud walking onto the stage. Even though I’m represented by numerous speaking agencies (and I make them good money) and even though I know for a fact that I have the knowledge, skills and experience to get the job done, I somehow find a way to feel inadequate. Unqualified. Unworthy. Not enough.

As I said, self-doubt doesn’t make sense.

The “I’m Not Good Enough” Disease

Today, I had a lengthy phone call with a friend who has a successful business in another state of Australia. She is bubbly, positive, inspiring, likable and fun to be around. She educates and motivates people towards their best lives. Outwardly, she’s a picture of confidence, control and calm. And, she’s fantastic at her job. Inwardly, she has an ongoing battle with the “I’m not good enough” disease.

Everyone thinks she’s great, except her. :(

Interestingly, the fact that people think she’s so amazing makes her feel even worse because in the middle of all their respect, gratitude and adoration, she feels like she’s constantly hiding the real her. You know: the crappy, stupid, talentless her. The fraud they don’t know. Sad huh?

And very common. 

Not Weird, Normal

Today I’m here to tell you that the self-doubt you feel is NORMAL! The feeling of being a fraud is NORMAL!

So, in the middle of our self-doubt, the challenge for you and me is to recognise those feelings for what they are and what they aren’t. What they are, is feelings. Not facts. They are negative emotions. Limiting beliefs. One of the many manifestations of fear. What they aren’t, is you. Your potential. Your possibilities.

Your future.

It’s our job (me and you, that is) to ‘feel the fear and do it anyway’. It’s our job to not let those feelings determine our behaviours, sabotage our potential or waste any more of our precious time. If I were to wait until I had no issues, no flaws and no self-doubt, I’d never do anything, write anything, create anything or learn anything because fear would be running my life.

Mistakes = Lessons

Personally, I’d rather make a few mistakes, fall down a few times and look like a dick sometimes than be controlled by, or limited by, fear. The more mistakes I make, the more I’m having a go, the more I’m learning and the more I’m growing. Self-doubt is part of the human condition. It does not make you (or me) a freak. Acknowledge it for what it is (a lying, disempowering thief) and then do what needs to be done. Let go of your ego. Face your fears. Get uncomfortable.

And occasionally, be prepared to look like a dick. ;)

Love this article? Sign up for my FREE Email Newsletter today to receive more articles like this, and my FREE Ebook!

{ 43 comments… read them below or add one }

Anonymous May 12, 2011 at 2:42 am

fake it until u make it always works

Reply

Anonymous May 12, 2011 at 3:27 am

yes!

Reply

J.D. Meier May 12, 2011 at 3:27 am

Beautiful insights.

I think doubt is a by-product of what we focus on — the questions we ask ourselves, where we put our focus, and the thoughts we think.

I think there’s a powerful pattern that melts away self-doubt when you focus on the bigger picture or playing a different role in the situation. For example, just shifting from “I don’t have anything useful to share” to “What can I share that might be useful?” changes everything.

Reply

Rafael May 12, 2011 at 5:39 am

Craig ! You totally blow me away! What a relief! Thanks!

Reply

Anonymous May 12, 2011 at 7:28 am

Hi

I often have the I am not good enough feeling of late. Last night I have a dream and was abducted by a weird cult. They injected me practically everywhere with Botox , sedated me , gave me a boob job and dressed me in sexy clothes and did liposuction all I was trying to do was find a phone that worked to call 000 to escape and go home and I fought their changes. In my dream I escaped and the woke up? Exhausted – would never do any of the above in real life? What the ? I go okay in my current life.

Reply

JoBeth May 12, 2011 at 7:37 am

Craig – you totally hit the nail on the head and at a very relevant time…I’m about to change jobs within our business. I have been told it’s because I’m being underutilised right now and I’ve been doing a great job (but I feel like a fraud in my current job and actually if they knew the truth they wouldn’t give me the new job…I feel I’m not going to be good enough for the new job). You’re right, feel the fear and do it anyway! Well yes I will!

Looking forward to your workshop on Sunday :-)

Reply

Craig May 12, 2011 at 9:42 am

Sunday week Deb.

I hope. ;)

Reply

Deb May 12, 2011 at 8:35 am

Bloody good timing!…needed this…luv u.

Reply

Craig May 12, 2011 at 9:41 am

Thanks for the luv Deb x

Reply

In need of serious therapy May 12, 2011 at 9:38 am

OMG this is totally me! I feel like a fraud in my job, however I get on with it. Pushing myself all the time. Putting in way too many hours so ‘they’ won’t know I am a fraud…then I get more work. What do I do….eat and drink to try and calm myself down…aaaahhhhh!

Reply

Simon May 12, 2011 at 9:39 am

Boom – Craig you have done it again.
I need to be more of a dick – challenge myself more and get out of my safety zone….
and mate never give up your style of writing – straight up and direct is how we like it :)

Reply

sweetpea May 12, 2011 at 9:43 am

Learned this lesson very early in life…I was on a stage performing, because I loved it (and still do). Now, the terrifying thing about being a “dick” it’s kinda okay privately, but being a dick “publicly” in front of hundreds of people. Over thirty years, have scrupulously kicked the fear and wantingor needing approval crud to curb because of this intense training. You could always hear the first row..”.look at her hair, look at her shoes…ooo and her boobs (lack of them actually)..”. yep..a crucifixion …but I loved the artform…and ego was never part of the equation. Great musicians to work with, and looking beyond the second row..learned to accept them, not take me to seriously…and every night I was on a trapeze without a net below.. exhilarating… present moment stuff… fast forward a few years in a different “comfort zone” training for new career to sustain me during the “leaner times”…at university with a very clever lecturer from Oxford…(very cool actually) Shakespearean sonnets… tutorial.. now Dr.Dingley says..(yes real name) Who can tell me what a “wandering bark” is? …no one wanted to answer…. cringe cringe (back at school) You Ms Sweetpea? ummmm (I try to wing it here…and just be a dick with confidence) a stray dog? Needless to say dear Doc looked me straight in the eyes..gave a very wry smile and turned to much younger students …do you agree with Ms Sweetpea? Noone answered answered because they did not know…needless to say I was hilariously wrong…being fearful can create.the best humour… being a deadset dick propelled the good doctor and I to become the best of friends and colleagues…and he only told me later that my comment got a great and “hearty guffaw” amongst the literati nobs in the department…
Moral of my story 1. If ya gonna be dick, be the best dick possible…because noone else knew I was being a dick…xcept the good doctor who then used to ring me at home if I was not in the tutorial…where are you? You have to attend (sick with the flu I say) nooo you have to be here….its two loooong hours…they never speak..you know that…I’ll send a cab. Moral 2. I reckon I have made more lifelong friends when being a shlemiel/dick. (which is me warts and all..self doubts and all… than being Ms Perfectomundo .another form of dick with no sense of humour…… As you age I think more shlemieldom is possible..and probable… but I am very happy and comfy with my warts now..intense training all those years helped…. they bring on the best and most memorable experiences and attract the “best” people..add a little more teflon…and less velcro…and try to contribute …authentically some will dig it…some wont… ce la vie…

Reply

Craig May 12, 2011 at 12:42 pm

That’s not a comment – that’s a new post Sweetpea!

Loved it. :)

Reply

Kim May 12, 2011 at 9:44 am

Wow, I just went through a big stage of feeling like a total fraud at work. Starting to come out of it now, but it’s nice to know that other people feel like that from time to time. Thanks Craig :)

Reply

Gullu May 12, 2011 at 10:39 am

Hi Craig,

A writer is a person who produces literary content, including but not limited to stories, poetry, music and other literary art, advertising, procedures, and books. No where does it make reference to the style of content etc. You are one of the best writers I have read to date….because you make sense. Not like the acedemic writers (I mean they are required of course, for difference purposes) you give us the ‘chat style’ of writing. Which we all at “me.dot.com” love.

When it comes to your human offerings of selflessness and humble caring style, you should have NO self doubt….as a catwalk model, well that may be another story!

Luv ya work.

Gullu

Reply

Evan May 12, 2011 at 10:48 am

If we trace those feelings to the source we can find things that need healing.

Listening to our wounds is not easy, but can provide invaluable information.

Reply

suse May 12, 2011 at 11:30 am

Thanks for the post very timely.

I am currently working in a job in an industry I know nothing about with no training.At first I couldn’t get the hang of anything and felt such a fraud but I have stuck it out and it is starting to come together.I have been there a month but am still embarrassed to tell people what my job is as I have no confidence in my ability to give the correct information.

BTW Craig can we get an update on CJ.
Sweatpea -priceless

Reply

kate May 12, 2011 at 11:41 am

Yep! totally I can be teaching a gym class, sitting in a meeting and then all of a sudden its like what the hell am I doing here.. I dont know anything.

self doubt is massive in me…

Reply

Joyce May 12, 2011 at 12:14 pm

Wow, what a relief! I am not alone after all. Love all about the “feel the fear and do it anyway”. Gosh, I almost made myself believe that I was truly a fake and too right I was sad that people around me thought otherwise. I never thought of it as some negative motions. Humans are the only species who can scare themselves, sadly. Not very smart, are we?

Reply

C1 May 12, 2011 at 12:34 pm

Thanks C2, your humility allows us to feel ‘NORMAL’, felt that way on more than a few occassions.

Recently went to a high school reunion and it was amazing to watch so many successful and dynamic people revert to ‘type’ as soon as they were in the presence of their former peers. One on one they were their fantastic developed new selves but as soon as the old gang got together, bam! insecure scared weird teenagers re-appeared.

As a people watcher at the best of times, this was facinating to watch happen infront of my own eyes.

Reply

Craig May 12, 2011 at 12:44 pm

Nice to hear from you C1 – let me know when you’re in Melb and we’ll do lunch.. :)

Reply

Rene May 12, 2011 at 1:36 pm

Thanks Craig – I’m in the final throes of completing my MBA while working full time and running a home with teenagers – after nearly 3 years, for some reason lately I’ve felt that I’m not really capable & its all just been dumb luck! Weird, hey. Logic tells me my thoughts are wrong but that self-doubt keeps creeping in. I thought I must be a complete head case feeling this way! Thanks for showing me I’m as normal(?) as the rest of you! Now I’m off to conquer my fear and start my next assignment :)

Reply

Dragon May 12, 2011 at 3:59 pm

Hang in there Rene you CAN do it. And it will be worth it. I graduate tonight from mine and I remember having the same thoughts. You never know whats possible until you try…

Reply

sweetpea May 12, 2011 at 1:40 pm

Thanks Craigus, testament to your great posts..apologies ….go into campfire storytelling mode….(ye old wordy dick)

Now I propose that for those of us in other parts of Oz, A “Be your best Richard” lunch or dinner should be created. A weekend in Melbourne is cool for shopping, then going to the “Big Richard Din Din ” – meeting the great peoples on this site….in person, meeting Craig …tell a view yarns, buy a few books, get the T-Shirt???? Informal…meet, greet. eat and laugh…a lot. Whaddya say Craig and Craig’s management???? It would be a hoot…

Reply

Craig May 12, 2011 at 2:49 pm

Hmm, not a bad idea. Maybe we should do an informal(ish) dinner-meet-up-get-together-with-like-minded-people- thingy. Or lunch. Might just be you and me Sweetpea. ;)

Is anyone else interested?

Will there be cake?

Reply

Dragon May 12, 2011 at 4:03 pm

I’m in. No cake.

Reply

Ian May 13, 2011 at 7:20 am

Sounds like fun, but a long way from Brisbane. the cake better be good!!

Reply

Roz May 13, 2011 at 9:48 am

With a little bit of notice, I can get there

Reply

Jane May 13, 2011 at 11:16 pm

Im in with a few weeks notice… with Cheesecake..just let me know the flavour!!!??? :D

Reply

Tina Johnston May 14, 2011 at 12:39 am

Me… me…. me!!!!! With or without cake !

{{HUG}} Tina

Reply

J9 May 12, 2011 at 2:41 pm

You haven’t mentioned the 28 day challenge but hell, I gotta get this off my chest. I FAILED. Bizarre admitting it with todays post but there’s no escaping the truth – it got hard, I got really sore, and I stopped.

Reply

Nikki May 12, 2011 at 3:19 pm

Thanks for another great post Craig. What you’ve described actually has a name – “impostor syndrome”. I’ve struggled with this one for a long time! From what I’ve read on the topic it is extremely common in high-achieving women. Personally I reckon it’s probably just as prolific amongst men, but we all know men are less likely to admit they have those kinds of feelings, huh. Good on you for bringing this topic out into the open!

Reply

Dragon May 12, 2011 at 4:03 pm

I like this post a lot. I’d love to know how many times in my life I have had these thoughts. I’m grateful for the humble folk around who share a little piece of their insecurity to show that to “err is human” (Alexander Pope quote). Nice work mate.

Reply

Janine May 12, 2011 at 4:04 pm

Hell yeah! I would be at the Be your best Richard lunch :) I have met Craig and the crew before and had a blast as well as meeting some other fabulous like minded people :) So make that 3 Sweetpea.

And Craig I reackon the cheesecake would be the go :P

And self doubt, just to add to the actual post today. Huge. Like Craig keeps advising feel the fear, which I am doing but I am living with Terror almost daily regarding self doubt. My gracious boss has been slowly giving me more opportunities within the small business I work, and even though I spent 2 years studying (a huge fear confrontation in itself) and have worked there for over a year now I still fell like a fraud that smiles. Anxiety huge, where some days I struggle not to find a corner to huddle in.

My friends and fellow creators have more faith in me that I have ever had in myself. But yet I try to push forward. As I say, there is thinking with my head and thinking with my heart. My head tells me logically I am capable, but that is not the mode I most often run from. So I will persist……

Reply

Holly May 12, 2011 at 9:16 pm

Yes you will………with some hard love from time to time as I know you do the same to me.

I’m in for the lunch too!

Reply

Lisa May 12, 2011 at 5:59 pm

Been a bit quiet recently, soz! Holidays are yaaaay! Mostly.
Although in the midst of it all I’ve definitely been hit with the “not good enough” disease. Ugh.
It also caused the green-eyed monster to rear its ugly head, which is rare. DOUBLE UGH!
Thankfully I realised what was up so I haven’t been a complete asshat to my friends. I think. I hope.
Anyway. Yes. Thanks, as always, for a timely post! ( )

Reply

May May 12, 2011 at 7:24 pm

I love your articles. Every single one of them has spoken to me in some useful way. And I love the way you put ‘You’re welcome’ on the bottom of them because it shows a confidence that you know they are appreciated. Did you hear that Craig’s inner voice? LOL

Reply

Daniel M. Wood May 12, 2011 at 7:30 pm

It is important to see that you are only human. You will never be perfect, there is always room to improve.

What is important is that you give advice you can stand behind and that the people you give the advice to can put it to use and get positive results thanks to it.

I would only call someone a fraud if they give advice they don’t know anything about, advising people to do things that might as well hurt their opportunities as help them.

Reply

amanda May 13, 2011 at 12:08 am

Hi. I’m in Canberra but I would willingly jump on a plane to (wonderful) Melbourne for the day to have a lunch or some sort of gathering. I make an EXCELLENT Chocolate Date Torte which I’d happily bring along to any event. Thanks to you Craig and best wishes to everyone else!
Amanda

Reply

Anonymous May 13, 2011 at 10:14 am

What you said hit me square between the eyes Craig.

I’ve been on a weight loss plan for the last year and a half and 34 kilos in with 22 to go I am getting lots of compliments and congratulations. But I am finding it really hard to deal with because I know the last 5 months have been long hard months motivationally and yoyoing weight loss wise and I dont feel like I deserve the praise.
It just leads to these feelings of guilt all the time because I know I am not doing everything properly and Im just like everyone else in the daily struggle with their weight issues and I dont want to be held up as the example for others to follow.
Im thinking its probably the perfectionist in me and that its okay to not be doing everything right all the time so long as you keep true to yourself and just keep going with that end goal in sight. Definite feelings of inadequacy here.

Reply

Tina Johnston May 14, 2011 at 12:53 am

Hey Craig,
Just to add my bit to the self-doubt conversation, well, it’s something I’ve struggled with all my life, in just about everything I’ve ever done. My most recent experience relates to the “reborn” baby dolls I make… I felt like a total fraud the day I accepted payment for my first “order”. I was sure it really wasn’t worth the price I was asking… which, I might add, was much less than other artists charge. But when the lady who taught me the art constantly tells me how much she loves my “babies” and that she would happily buy one from me…. well, I guess that says something !
{{HUG}} Tina

Reply

Lost Lliving May 14, 2011 at 6:30 am

I’ve had those feeling before. It doesn’t feel good.

Reply

Fraud May 14, 2011 at 5:14 pm

I really doubt this post will help ;)

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 5 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: