Gaining Weight to Lose Weight

Hi Guys. Today I will be appearing as (okay, writing as) the Exercise Scientist. The following information will be more interesting and educational than it will be motivating and inspiring (as such). It won’t be hilarious or particularly amusing either but I think many of you who are looking to Renovate Your Body (or simply lose some lard) will find it relevant, thought-provoking and possibly, enlightening.

What Most of Us Want

Apart from world peace, inner peace, healthy kids, better relationships, a ticket to heaven, a Golden Retriever that doesn’t crap, moult or fart and an endless supply of unconditional love and foot rubs from our partner, what is it we all want?  A smaller arse, of course. And stomach. Legs. Arms. In fact, pick a body part. Over the years, the vast majority of people who have walked through the door of my gym for the first time have had one thing in common: a desire to be leaner. There are very few people who go to a gym (or start an exercise program at home for that matter) who don’t want to lose a little flab.

Now, being as losing flab essentially comes down to the equation of energy intake (calories in our gob) versus energy expenditure (calories burned), it makes sense that we should explore ways to increase our energy expenditure without having to get too creative, hard-core or uber-athletic and without having to (necessarily) increase our training time. While there are many ways to manipulate the intensity and resultant effects of exercise on our body, today I want to discuss a very simple but effective concept: making our body heavier (for an hour or so) while we exercise.

That’s right, the more weight we carry, the more energy we expend carrying that weight so why not opt for some temporary weight gain to speed up your weight loss? Now you’re interested aren’t you?

Knew it.

What is a Weight Vest?

A weight vest is a training (exercise) tool that can be used for a range of applications, in a range of situations and settings for anyone from the unfit novice exerciser through to the elite athlete. As the name indicates (and the picture shows), it is a vest to be worn while people exercise or participate in almost any kind of physical activity. Those activities might range from domestic duties (gardening and vacuuming) through to elite-level fitness and sports training (sprinting, climbing, plyometrics, aerobic endurance, muscular endurance and much more). These days, using a weight vest is commonplace among athletes at the pointy end of their sport. The vest has compartments (pockets) which allow the user to load up to 140lbs (64kgs) of weight.

While the weight vest has a wide range of high-performance applications and potential physical benefits, today I want to focus on the one benefit that is (typically) of greatest interest to most people who don’t fall into the elite athlete category: increasing calorie expenditure while exercising (with the goal of decreasing bodyfat and weight). Yep, that’s right; the weight vest is a simple (yet effective) tool that allows the user to drastically increase his or her energy expenditure (that is, calorie burning) while completing their regular tasks, activities and/or workouts.  

For example, the person who walks 7km (4.2mi) every day (a random distance chosen by me and used in the tables below) can significantly improve their aerobic and muscular endurance and drastically increase their energy expenditure (cals burned) by simply adding some weight to their walk. They don’t need to walk any further, faster or more often. They don’t need to develop a new skill or try a new activity. All they need to do is what they’ve done for the last (?) years while increasing the load a little (or for some, a lot) by adding some weight to the process.

To give you an idea of how effective adding weight to your exercise program can be, I’ve done some rudimentary calculations based on a 75kg (165lb) person completing a sixty-minute walk at 7kph (4.2mph) with various weights added (table 1) and then the same for a 60kg (132lb) person (table 2). Take a minute to look at the tables and then I’ll discuss some of the implications, suggestions and possibilities below.

Table 1

Person’s Weight Activity Duration Added weight Calories
Expended
Extra Calories
Expended
Increase in Calorie Expenditure (%)
75kg/165lbs Walk 7kph 4.2mph 60 mins 0 440 0 0
75kg/165lbs Walk 7kph 4.2mhp 60 mins 10kg/22lbs 497 57 13%
75kg/165lbs Walk 7kph
4mph
60 mins 20 kg/44lbs 554 114 25.5%
75kg/165lbs Walk 7kph
4mph
60 mins 30 kg/66lbs 611 171 38.9%

Table 2

Person’s Weight Activity Duration Added weight Calories
Expended
Extra Calories
Expended
Increase in Calorie
Expenditure (%)
60kg/132lbs Walk 7 kph
4.2mph
60 mins 0 354 0 0
60kg/132lbs Walk 7 kph
4.2mph
60 mins 10kg/22lbs 411 57 16.1%
60kg/132lbs Walk 7 kph
4.2mph
60 mins 20 kg/44lbs 469 115 32.9%
60kg/132lbs Walk 7 kph
4.2mph
60 mins 30 kg/66lbs 526 172 48.6%

aaaaaaa
If we look at table 2, we can see that a 60kg person can increase his/her energy expenditure by 16.1% by adding as little as 10kgs to their walk. This is a simple and (relatively) low-intensity way to burn a lot more calories over a typical week of walking. I also did some additional calculations based on my body-weight (95kgs/209lbs). By adding a 30kg/66lb vest to my daily walk, I would burn an extra 44,720 calories over a twelve month period (walking an average of five days per week). No greater time commitment, no faster walking pace, no further distance covered – just a heavier load. Not only would I be leaner at the end of that period (all things being equal), I would also be fitter (aerobically) and stronger because my heart, lungs and muscles would be under greater load (and therefore need to adapt accordingly).  

Potential Applications

I won’t explore the potential applications for elite sport in this post (I don’t believe it’s relevant for the majority of my readers), but I will say that a weight vest can be a valuable addition to almost any weight-bearing activity (walking, jogging, skipping, stair walking, climbing, hiking – and more) for anyone looking to change their body composition. I even know quite a few people who put on their weight vest around breakfast time (usually with a light to moderate load) and keep it on until lunch time. They simply go about their daily business (chores, responsibilities, activities) while laden with a few extra pounds. The net result? Increased energy expenditure and, ultimately, faster weight-loss.

*Note: extra weight also means extra load on ligaments, tendons, joints and discs – which naturally means a greater potential for injuries. Before you load yourself up with a bazillion pounds (1) make sure you’re good to go (see a doctor or highly-qualified fitness professional) and (2) build a training (fitness/strength) base before you start heaving around anything too heavy.

Now, before you write and ask, yes, you can improvise and create your own (version of a) weight vest. A decent backpack and a few bags of rice and sugar is always a good starting point. In fact, carrying additional weight anywhere on your body (carrying the groceries for example) will increase energy expenditure. Of course, the weight vest is not a stand-alone, all-purpose fitness or weight-loss solution. However, it certainly has the potential to be a great resource and a fantastic addition to our training bag.

Let me know your thoughts, ideas and experiences. :)

* I look forward to seeing a hundred (or so) of you this Sunday at my centre in Brighton for a little RYB love. And possibly a hug.

{ 7 trackbacks }

The Monday Myth
May 13, 2010 at 9:56 pm
The Discomfort Theory
May 13, 2010 at 9:59 pm
Tapping Into Your Potential
May 13, 2010 at 10:02 pm
The WHY behind the WHAT
May 13, 2010 at 10:06 pm
The Shrinking Family
May 13, 2010 at 10:08 pm
Random things to think about….
May 13, 2010 at 10:10 pm
A CHDC Update…
May 26, 2010 at 10:50 pm

{ 17 comments… read them below or add one }

Jen L May 13, 2010 at 8:48 pm

Hi, another benefit I found from my weight vest was a real ‘oh my god’ at just how much weight I had lost and how much better I would feel when I lost that last few kilos. I bought a weight vest that holds 9kg’s and was stunned at just how much heavier and harder it was to put that vest on and walk, and at that time, i had lost 27 kg’s (so was previously carrying around 3 times that amount). I am still blown away by how I actually managed to walk around with that extra 27kg’s. I think that in addition to the extra calories burned using the vest, the mere thought of carrying that extra weight and how great I would feel when the last 9 or so kilos was gone, helped me to work harder even when not using the vest.

That reminds me, haven’t used that vest in a while, might be time to help with the last kilos still trying to lose.

Looking forward to meeting you on Sunday.

cheers
Jen

Pip May 13, 2010 at 9:11 pm

Wow, I knew there was a reason why I always volunteer to do the ‘heavy lifting’, to shift the coke and alcohol cartons orders in my employment, to beat others to jobs of lifting and carrying heavy uncomfortable things!

I will have to keep this little secret hehe!

Pip :-)

Matt May 13, 2010 at 9:30 pm

Cool looking vest! I’ve seen them used for pullups, lunges, step ups, pushups, box jumping, squats, and other assorted exercises. They have many applications.

FCR May 13, 2010 at 9:45 pm

Good article Graig.
My suggestion would be to try putting weight plates in a small backpack, wrapped in a towel to cushion against your back. It has the same effect.

corrine May 13, 2010 at 10:05 pm

Will my back suffer as a result? How much do they cost?

Kelsey May 13, 2010 at 10:32 pm

It is my experience that weight vests not only help to strengthen your heart, but also encourage the maintenance of healthy bone density.

Portal 4 Health May 13, 2010 at 11:00 pm

[...] Gaining Weight to Lose Weight [...]

Steve Jowett May 14, 2010 at 7:35 am

As a specialist supplier of weight vest products i can speak first hand albeit in a biased way about the effectiveness of adding a weighted vest to your training regime. Your article points out the benefits of adding weight loading to a simple cardio activity such as walking. As soon as you put on your vest you begin to expend more energy. Consider even the benefits of a using a vest when you go about your household chores such as cleaning the house and yard. A good vest will be comfortable to wear and will evenly distribute the weight above your abdomen front and back so you maintain good balance. A well ventilated design will ensure breathing is not restricted and you will not suffer from overheating.

Weight loss is achieved and at the same time strength gains are also made. Simple activities such as sweeping a path or using the vacuum will develop core strength muscle. A more traditional set of exercises such as squats, pushups, pullups, and dips all payback with greater strength development in less time when the vest is used. Try a set of your usual exercises with the vest on then remove the vest and try without. You will feel like you suddenly obtained super powers.

By the way i am giving all you article readers 10% off our entire range of weighted vest products at http://www.strengthpoint.com just use the discount code “reader10″ when you checkout.

Have a great day!

KR17 May 14, 2010 at 7:44 am

Hi Craig. I love it when you get all sciencey and clever on us. Especially when your cleverness might help make my fat arse smaller. Today I’m off to investigate weight vests. Keep doing what you do and thanks for being the real deal minus all the bull***t.

That’s what we luv. Kaz. :)

Kate May 14, 2010 at 8:03 am

OMG I really hope that can be worn under a shirt… Im going to stick to spinning 600 calories in 45 mins.. and looks a hell of alot better!

Megan May 14, 2010 at 8:16 am

I am an ex-fattie (I’ve lost 21 kilos) and I have used a vest for over a year. I started using one at my gym and eventually bought my own. These days I walk with 12-15 kilos for about 30 minutes most days and I recently wore it on a bushwalk with my hubby. That was hard! But great. Like Craig said, they definitely work.

Craig May 14, 2010 at 8:27 am

Hi Corrine.

1. It’s impossible to answer the ‘back question’ as there are too many variables and too many unknowns from my point of view (I don’t know anything about you or your back). Having said that, vests don’t put excessive stress on backs if they are used the right way. If anything, over time using a vest should strengthen your back. If you have an existing back injury or condition (especially disc issues) I would advise you to not use a vest until you get clearance from the relevant medical professional.

2. They can cost anywhere from $150.00 up to $1,000. Typically, $250 should get you something that’s reasonable quality with reasonable weight. There are cheap ones but they tend to fall apart within months… :)

Pet May 14, 2010 at 9:32 am

Being a daily walker, this is the best idea ever. Never had I thought about a weighted vest for me. Geez Craig…..love your work.
As for loading up a backpack, that’s usually my backpack walking home from work. Esp. now that its getting cooler, the pack is heavier. My backpack has a light back support frame that is curved away from my back & then there is a mesh piece that sits on my back (its called a freeflow ventilation back system) I have tried a few backpacks & this one is the best. Its light & comfortable, even when fully loaded….but expensive…..but worth it. But I will look into a vest for when I’m walking my dogs :-)

I hope RYB goes fabulously on Sunday.

Pet
xoxo
PS How nice of Steve to offer the 10% discount.

Jen N May 14, 2010 at 10:24 am

I’ve seen elite athletes wearing them but I’ve never considered using one myself! I have difficulty walking since a serious MVA afew years ago, but I love to exercise. I’ve combated not being able to walk much by buying a pedal exerciser that I use 6 days pw. It gives me a brilliant cardio workout. Please tell me if a vest would work ok on a bike as I’m stationary (except for my legs)?

Have a wonderful day & weekend!

Jen :)

Nick May 14, 2010 at 4:41 pm

I have been using the vests for a while and it is great to tool to burn those extra calories but also reinforce to your clients about how hard it is on the body to carry that extra weight and what damage you can be doing to your body when you are overweight.

Success Demands Action May 15, 2010 at 1:41 pm

Hey there loving the blog! I was wondering if you would be interested in exchanging links? I am looking add more great self improvement blogs to my blog roll. Let me know if you wanna exchange links :)

Success Demands Action: A Self Improvement Blog

Mister Manly June 30, 2010 at 11:53 pm

Hi Craig, great article and I can say that I have been using my Hart 10kg weighted vest for almost 2-weeks and am really starting to see a change in my muscularity (esp legs which are leaner but definitely stronger ie calves/hammys and quads)! BTW I’m not in anyway affiliated to Hart but went with theirs as they use sand for the weights not solid plates (which means that it doesn’t dig into me while I am wearing it around home or during my workouts, including lying down on bench doing presses etc -> this feature was and has been a real benefit, especially when I have been wearing it for 3-4hrs!!)

I absolutely agree about how effective it is (really good for bodyweight circuit training, weights and interval training) and would recommend a weighted vest to anyone who feels their training has plateaued ie not seeing results or is in a hurry to get results (like me). Keep up the good work, Mr M :)

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: